top of page
Search

GSTR-2A Mismatch Can't Deny ITC: New GSTAT Ruling Explained

Writer: Rishi Mehta
Rishi Mehta
Oct 14
4 min read

If your business has ever received a GST notice simply because the input tax credit (ITC) claimed in your GSTR-3B did not match the figures reflected in GSTR-2A, a recent ruling from the GST Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) is worth your attention. In an order delivered by the Lucknow Bench, the Tribunal held that a mismatch between GSTR-3B and GSTR-2A, by itself, cannot be the basis for denying ITC. The claim must instead be examined against the verification procedure laid down by the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC) in Circular No. 183/15/2022-GST.

For thousands of small and medium businesses still dealing with legacy ITC disputes from the early years of GST (FY 2017-18 and FY 2018-19, when return-filing systems were far less mature than they are today), this ruling is a timely reminder of the safeguards already built into the law, and of how easily they can be overlooked by assessing officers and first-level appellate authorities.

What Happened in This Case

The appellant, a proprietor trading under the name Shakti Iron Stores, had ITC denied for FY 2017-18 on the ground that the credit claimed in GSTR-3B exceeded what was visible in GSTR-2A, the auto-populated statement based on the supplier's returns. The first appellate authority dismissed the taxpayer's appeal after he failed to appear for a hearing, citing medical reasons for his absence.

On further appeal, the GSTAT's Lucknow Bench set aside this approach. The Tribunal held that a GSTR-3B vs GSTR-2A mismatch is not, on its own, proof that credit was wrongly availed. According to the order, the mismatch has to be examined with supporting documentary evidence and through the verification mechanism that CBIC itself prescribed for exactly this kind of discrepancy (GSTAT order reported by Taxscan).

Why CBIC Circular No. 183/15/2022-GST Matters

CBIC had issued Circular No. 183/15/2022-GST specifically to deal with ITC mismatches between GSTR-3B and GSTR-2A for FY 2017-18 and FY 2018-19, the period before GSTR-2B (a static, more reliable ITC statement) was introduced. The circular recognised that early GST returns were prone to reporting errors on the supplier's side, and it laid down a structured procedure for officers to follow, rather than allowing an automatic denial of credit:

  • Where the difference between the two returns is up to Rs 5 lakh for a financial year, a certificate from a chartered accountant or cost accountant confirming that the supplier has actually paid the tax on the relevant supplies is sufficient evidence.

  • Where the difference exceeds Rs 5 lakh, the taxpayer must obtain a certificate from the supplier's own chartered accountant or cost accountant, along with other corroborating documents such as invoices and payment proof.

  • Only after this verification process is exhausted, and the officer is still not satisfied that tax was paid by the supplier, can the credit be denied.

In short, the circular was designed as a safety net for genuine taxpayers caught in reconciliation gaps that were largely outside their control. The GSTAT's Lucknow Bench ruling reinforces that this safety net cannot simply be bypassed by assessing officers or first appellate authorities who treat a numerical mismatch as conclusive proof of wrongdoing.

Why This Matters Now

Several factors make this ruling particularly relevant for Indian businesses today. The GST Appellate Tribunal became operational across state benches only earlier in 2026, after years of delay since its introduction was first proposed in 2017. Many taxpayers with pending ITC disputes from the early GST years are only now getting a genuine appellate forum to test orders that were passed, sometimes mechanically, by tax officers and first appellate authorities. This ruling is an early signal of how GSTAT benches are approaching such matters: with an emphasis on due process and documentary verification rather than a reflexive reading of return-matching data.

It is also a useful reminder that an ITC mismatch notice is not, by default, a lost cause. Taxpayers who can demonstrate that their supplier genuinely paid the tax, even if the supplier's own compliance was delayed or imperfect, have a reasonable basis to contest denial, provided they follow the documentation route the circular prescribes.

A Practical Checklist for Businesses and Taxpayers

  • If you have received, or are contesting, an ITC denial notice for FY 2017-18 or FY 2018-19 based on a GSTR-3B vs GSTR-2A mismatch, check whether the officer followed the verification steps under Circular No. 183/15/2022-GST before passing the order.

  • For mismatches up to Rs 5 lakh in a financial year, keep a chartered accountant's or cost accountant's certificate ready, confirming that the supplier has paid tax on the relevant supplies.

  • For larger mismatches, be prepared to obtain a certificate from the supplier's own CA or cost accountant, supported by invoices, e-way bills, and payment records.

  • Where an appeal was dismissed for non-appearance due to genuine reasons (illness, for instance), explore whether a further appeal or rectification application is still available within the limitation period.

  • Maintain supplier-wise reconciliation statements between GSTR-2A/2B and your purchase register as a matter of routine, not only when a notice arrives, since this evidence is what ultimately supports an ITC claim.

  • Track GSTAT bench orders in your jurisdiction, as the Tribunal is still building a body of precedent that will shape how similar disputes are resolved going forward.

Conclusion

The Lucknow Bench's ruling is a welcome clarification for businesses still untangling ITC disputes from GST's early, imperfect years. It confirms that a return-matching discrepancy is a starting point for verification, not an automatic ground for denial, and that the procedural safeguards CBIC built into Circular No. 183/15/2022-GST must actually be followed by tax authorities. For taxpayers, the takeaway is equally practical: good documentation and timely professional certification remain the strongest defence against an ITC mismatch notice, whether the matter is still at the departmental stage or has reached the Appellate Tribunal.

If your business is facing an ITC mismatch notice, a pending GST appeal, or simply wants to put in place a robust reconciliation process to avoid such disputes altogether, the team at CA Samir K. Mehta & Associates can help you review your position and plan the right course of action. Contact us today to discuss your specific case.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page